Top 36 - First Group

Join us during showtime and chat with us in the Shoutbox to the left! We had 6 people last week...let's get to 10!!

So...on with the show!


Jackie – A Little Less Conversation – Terrible! This was your one shot and this what you came up with?!? The clothes and the Playboy bunny necklace was dated. This is a singing competition. So the best vocal is what we are looking for.


Ricky – A Song For You – Really good performance. I liked him. I agreed with Simon that he has to come away from the nice guy persona. But great job on that song. http://www.rickey.org/?p=11805




Alexis – I Never Loved A Man - I loved you – I would have picked a better song for her. I think that performance should have been saved for latter. I think she should have done an Alicia Keyes song. More up-to-date.



Brent - Hicktown – I think we are done with Country singers. He can sing, but so what! Not the next Idol. Thanks for playing.



Stevie – You Belong To Me - Terrible!!! She was off key most of the song. Dumb Song. Nervous. Bad, bad, bad.



Anoop – Angel of Mine – Bad song choice!!!!! I liked him so much during the auditions. Too safe. He is going home.



Casey – Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic – Terrible. Bad. Train wreck. Pleas stop.




Michael – I Don’t Want To Be – Bo Bice did this song waaay better. I wasn’t feeling this performance. Not great…just ok. He can do better.




Ann Marie – Natural Woman – She was really nervous. I think she was just good. Bad notes. Song was bigger than her.



Stephen – Rock With You – Bad lounge act!!! Big disappointment.




Tatianna – Saving All My Love For You – Not bad. Just boring. She’s got pipes.




Danny – Hero – He did a great job! He knocked it out of the park. I was worried about the song. But he did great. http://www.rickey.org/?p=11841



My guess at the vote is that Danny will make it for the boys, Alexis for the girls. Tatianna will be the next highest vote getter. I think the judges will bring back Ricky as the wild card at the end of the season. Or they should. They might surprise me and give Michael another chance. I thought Ricky was better than Michael…but who knows! We shall see tomorrow. Remember to vote!!! Until tomorrow…c-ya!