Top 8 Girls

Paula was obviously on crack tonight. She shared some with Simon. They rambled on so much that Syesha got one word evaluations. The boys were better as a whole.

Asia'h - Good song choice. It was a good performance. I think she should do some Anita Baker or Toni Braxton with her deep voice in the future. She was ok.

Kady - If she makes it, 100% because of her lucks. She was terrible. And she has such a good voice.

Amanda - Different song, same performance. That's my major issue with her. I have seen absolutely nothing new from her.

Carly - Hated the song. She should do soul! So that she can stand out. She sounds too kaorke when she does rock. SHE can do Whitney or Chaka Khan.

Kristy - Good performance. I think she is getting better. Unfortunately I agree with Simon, she doesn't stand out.

Ramiele - Too young and inexperienced for this competition. She can sing, but she lacks the confidence to do the performances well. But she has the "mutts" on her side. The more Paula talked...the deeper she got!

Brooke - I thought it was nice, but nothing new. I want to see the other side of her. Not sure there is one. Remember Jewell made more $$$ when she dropped the whole homeless act and went pop. But Mrs.-Brooke-neve-watched-an-r-rated-movie may not have another side.

Syesha - I thought she did well. But if you close your eyes and think of Lakisha from last year singing that song and then open your eyes and see Syesha, you understand what Simon means we he says the song is too big. But a good enough performance to get her through.

Top 2 performance: Brooke and Amanda (they both stuck to the same formula). Bottom 2: Kady and Ramielle. But Ramielle has a big fan base...so it will probably be Kady and Kristy. We shall see....