Top 6 perform

Andrew Lloyd Webber night

This can really show people who shine or be really, really bad. Even worse than the previous themes because you have to have a big voice to sing Broadway. Let’s see how they do…

Up first, Syesha: I didn’t like it. She started off on the wrong beat (look at Asian composer looking around confused). I thought her voice was weak. I didn’t like it. Because it didn’t suck doesn’t mean it was good. I don’t think she has a Broadway voice like Jennifer Hudson or Fantasia. I don’t think she will be the worse tonight but a weak performance.

John Castro: Please oh please send him home. What a terrible pre-video! Basically Andrew said he was and idiot. That we know. But damn! Ok…the performance is not the best. It started off better than I thought. It then fell apart when he tried to use his lower register. It didn’t completely suck. Which is making me really, really mad because I want him to go home!!!! I think he should have totally picked another song.

I like Andrew Lloyd Webber. Brutally honest.

Brooke: Ok. I think I have recovered. I spent about 5 minutes in SHOCK with the show on pause (thank heavens for a DVR!!!). OMG. That had to be the single most shocking and embarrassing moment in Idol history! Big props for her getting it back together. I thought this was on its way to being her best performance, not vocally, but the performance. I think minus the slip, it still was. I did feel it and I thought she did too. I compared this to Madonna’s version. I thought it was good to see her in a different light. Stronger. I’m glad she stretched herself. I am very glad she listened and didn’t speak to the judges. She was fighting back tears and I’m glad she won. Big ups!!!

Loving me some Andrew Lloyd Webber

David A: Beautiful vocally. He was struggling to keep those eyes open. I agree 100%. When he opened his eyes he seemed to get more emotional. It allows him to better express some else besides golly gee shucks. I agree with Simon. He should stay but not a stand out performance. Pretty, but no chills.

Did I say how much I love Andrew Lloyd Webber

Carly: That’s my girl!!! She brought it! Are you kidding?!?! That performance was the bomb. I will note that Paula knows her music and that Carly cheated with the chorus. I agreed that it still sounded good.

David Cook: Wow! Chills. Man, he is the one to beat. I’m loving me some David Cook. Wow! Versatility!!!! Man. Wow. That’s all I can say. David A is such a little boy compared to him.

I loved this night. I had everything! Long live Idol!!

I can’t call it!!! It should be John Castro. But who knows what America will do.

See you all tomorrow!