AI Top 10

Gwen as a host was like Sanjaya’s hair-do. Interesting choice but sucked ass. Oh, maybe that should have been Gwen as a host and Ryan Seacrest on a date.

Lakisha – Good song choice. I wasn’t blown away but she sung it well. She is still in my top 2.


Chris Sligh – Terrible. I LOVE this song and he butchered it. His quirky style and quick wit is slowly wearing thin. At least he was respectful to Simon. But it may be time to go. I will also add that he is a Christian singer in his hometown and that kind of changed my opinion of him. Probably because I’m going to hell.


Gina – GREAT JOB! I was worried but she did a good job with that song. I agree, best of the night.


Sanjaya - So very, very painful. He picked a good song one that he basically speaks the entire time. He basically smiled through the parts he was forgetting. Good, get smart with Simon. Hopefully that will lose you votes.


Haley – Could have done this song well. She oversang it. The beauty of the song is that it is understated. She got better in the middle. First time I agreed with Gwen, just sing the song.


Phil – I thought it was a good choice of song. I typically think he sounds like a hack. I like him in hats so I can focus


Melinda – I hate that song! But good to see her dance a little. She seemed a little too old for the competition with this song. But maybe because it’s dated as hell. I hate that song! She can sing, but I would rate that performance a B+. On Best Week Ever they were clowning her on how her neck sort of disappears when she scrunches? So maybe I’m being a hater because I was distracted. I hate that song! She DID try very hard to do that surprised look, so good for you for listening to millions of people tell you to cut it out! But of course, she looked a little weird. Just can’t win!


Blake – Great song choice, but WAY too slow. It was boring.


Jordan – Yuck! Love her but she should always do sure thing. Gwen thought it was musical this time because the music wins over vocals on this song. So not a good choice. But loving her and think she is doing a great job.


Chris R – Started really cool and jazzy. Just like Elliott Yamin, they don’t know how to package him. Same look every week. This song is slowly getting worse and coming across as karaoke. He should have left it jazzy and soft and not go all Justin on it.


I say either Chris and Haley should go home. I can’t call it. PLEASE let it be Sanjaya. Until tomorrow, C-ya!